Where language families began
For each family: the positions specialists hold, the evidence for and against each, a schematic map, and the split dates from published trees.
Indo-European
Where and when was Proto-Indo-European spoken?
- Pontic–Caspian steppeMAJORITY— The mainstream view, with a credible minority dissenting.
- Caucasus–Lower Volga (Indo-Anatolian)CONTESTED— A live debate with no clear majority, or a recent challenge not yet absorbed.
- South of the Caucasus, with a later steppe stageCONTESTED— A live debate with no clear majority, or a recent challenge not yet absorbed.
- Anatolia, with early farmingCONTESTED— A live debate with no clear majority, or a recent challenge not yet absorbed.
Dravidian
Where was Proto-Dravidian spoken?
- Southern NeolithicCONTESTED— A live debate with no clear majority, or a recent challenge not yet absorbed.
- North-west, including the Indus regionCONTESTED— A live debate with no clear majority, or a recent challenge not yet absorbed.
Sino-Tibetan
Where did Sino-Tibetan begin?
- Millet farmers of northern ChinaMAJORITY— The mainstream view, with a credible minority dissenting.
- South-western China or north-east IndiaCONTESTED— A live debate with no clear majority, or a recent challenge not yet absorbed.
Austronesian
How did Austronesian spread from Taiwan?
- Out of Taiwan, in pulses and pausesMAJORITY— The mainstream view, with a credible minority dissenting.
- Slow boat: ancestry from Island Southeast AsiaCONTESTED— A live debate with no clear majority, or a recent challenge not yet absorbed.
Bantu
Which way did the Bantu languages spread south?
- Through the rainforestMAJORITY— The mainstream view, with a credible minority dissenting.
- Along a savanna corridorCONTESTED— A live debate with no clear majority, or a recent challenge not yet absorbed.