Altaic / Transeurasian
CONTESTED— A live debate with no clear majority, or a recent challenge not yet absorbed.Once a standard grouping
Turkic, Mongolic and Tungusic, and in the larger version Koreanic and Japonic, descend from one ancestor.
- Members
- Turkic, Mongolic-Khitan, Tungusic, Koreanic, Japonic“Micro-Altaic” is Turkic, Mongolic and Tungusic; “Macro-Altaic” or Transeurasian adds Koreanic and Japonic.
- Proposed by
- Ramstedt; Poppe; Starostin; Robbeets
- Evidence offered
- A 2021 study combines cognate sets from 98 languages, archaeology and ancient DNA, and links the spread to millet farmers of the West Liao River in north-east China.3
- Main critiques
- Most comparativists since the 1950s treat the similarities as areal, the result of long contact; Macro-Altaic is “widely rejected, even by many Altaicists”.5
- A 2022 reanalysis finds that only a small share of the 2021 cognate sets appear in more than one family, and that the archaeology and genetics do not support the farming narrative.4
Debate
Did the Transeurasian languages spread with early millet farmers?
A 2021 study argues that Turkic, Mongolic, Tungusic, Koreanic and Japonic descend from one language spread by millet farmers from north-east China. A 2022 reanalysis argues that none of the three lines of evidence supports that account, and the original authors replied that combining them reduces the error. Most comparativists treat Altaic resemblances as the result of contact.
Spread with millet farmers
CONTESTED— A live debate with no clear majority, or a recent challenge not yet absorbed.Transeurasian languages spread with millet farmers from the West Liao River in the early Neolithic, with a root about 9,181 years ago (95% interval 5,595–12,793).
- Held by
- Held by Robbeets et al. 2021; Robbeets et al. 2022 (reply)
- Sources
- Robbeets et al. 2021; Robbeets et al. 2022
The evidence does not support it
CONTESTED— A live debate with no clear majority, or a recent challenge not yet absorbed.Few cognate sets are shared across families, the archaeology has little phylogenetic signal, and the genetics do not support a farming spread of these languages.
- Held by
- Held by Tian et al. 2022
- Sources
- Tian et al. 2022
What would settle it
- Regular sound correspondences across the five families in basic vocabulary, accepted by specialists in each.