Skip to content
inkglot

Macro-families: proposed, not established

Glottolog 5.4 recognises 237 language families, plus isolates. Many proposals would join some of them into larger families. None is accepted; this page shows each with its evidence and the case against it.

  • Accepted family (Glottolog), consensus
  • Contested proposal
  • Fringe or rejected (on request)
Altaic / Transeurasian: contestedDené–Yeniseian: contestedAustro-Tai: contestedNiger-Congo (as a whole): contestedNilo-Saharan: contestedAtlantic-Congo: 1409 languages (Glottolog)Austronesian: 1280 languages (Glottolog)Indo-European: 587 languages (Glottolog)Sino-Tibetan: 521 languages (Glottolog)Afro-Asiatic: 381 languages (Glottolog)Nuclear Trans New Guinea: 318 languages (Glottolog)Pama-Nyungan: 250 languages (Glottolog)Otomanguean: 181 languages (Glottolog)Austroasiatic: 158 languages (Glottolog)Tai-Kadai: 95 languages (Glottolog)Dravidian: 83 languages (Glottolog)Arawakan: 77 languages (Glottolog)Mande: 75 languages (Glottolog)Tupian: 70 languages (Glottolog)Uto-Aztecan: 69 languages (Glottolog)Central Sudanic: 63 languages (Glottolog)Nilotic: 56 languages (Glottolog)Nuclear Torricelli: 55 languages (Glottolog)Uralic: 49 languages (Glottolog)Algic: 47 languages (Glottolog)Athabaskan-Eyak-Tlingit: 46 languages (Glottolog)Pano-Tacanan: 45 languages (Glottolog)Hmong-Mien: 44 languages (Glottolog)Quechuan: 43 languages (Glottolog)Turkic: 43 languages (Glottolog)Cariban: 42 languages (Glottolog)Kru: 38 languages (Glottolog)Nakh-Daghestanian: 36 languages (Glottolog)Mayan: 34 languages (Glottolog)Nuclear-Macro-Je: 29 languages (Glottolog)Chibchan: 27 languages (Glottolog)Tucanoan: 26 languages (Glottolog)Salishan: 25 languages (Glottolog)Dogon: 20 languages (Glottolog)Mixe-Zoque: 19 languages (Glottolog)Siouan: 18 languages (Glottolog)Japonic: 17 languages (Glottolog)Mongolic-Khitan: 17 languages (Glottolog)Tungusic: 15 languages (Glottolog)Khoe-Kwadi: 14 languages (Glottolog)Eskimo-Aleut: 13 languages (Glottolog)Miwok-Costanoan: 13 languages (Glottolog)Totonacan: 13 languages (Glottolog)Chapacuran: 12 languages (Glottolog)Cochimi-Yuman: 12 languages (Glottolog)Iroquoian: 11 languages (Glottolog)Ijoid: 10 languages (Glottolog)Saharan: 10 languages (Glottolog)Songhay: 10 languages (Glottolog)Chocoan: 9 languages (Glottolog)Tuu: 9 languages (Glottolog)Kiowa-Tanoan: 8 languages (Glottolog)Arawan: 7 languages (Glottolog)Chukotko-Kamchatkan: 7 languages (Glottolog)Huitotoan: 7 languages (Glottolog)Mataguayan: 7 languages (Glottolog)Muskogean: 7 languages (Glottolog)Pomoan: 7 languages (Glottolog)Barbacoan: 6 languages (Glottolog)Chumashan: 6 languages (Glottolog)Lengua-Mascoy: 6 languages (Glottolog)Nambiquaran: 6 languages (Glottolog)Wakashan: 6 languages (Glottolog)Yanomamic: 6 languages (Glottolog)Zaparoan: 6 languages (Glottolog)Abkhaz-Adyge: 5 languages (Glottolog)Caddoan: 5 languages (Glottolog)Guahiboan: 5 languages (Glottolog)Guaicuruan: 5 languages (Glottolog)Kartvelian: 5 languages (Glottolog)Kxa: 5 languages (Glottolog)Misumalpan: 5 languages (Glottolog)Sahaptian: 5 languages (Glottolog)Xincan: 5 languages (Glottolog)Yeniseian: 5 languages (Glottolog)Aymaran: 4 languages (Glottolog)Chinookan: 4 languages (Glottolog)Chonan: 4 languages (Glottolog)Huavean: 4 languages (Glottolog)Chicham: 4 languages (Glottolog)Kamakanan: 4 languages (Glottolog)Maiduan: 4 languages (Glottolog)Naduhup: 4 languages (Glottolog)Shastan: 4 languages (Glottolog)Yokutsan: 4 languages (Glottolog)Ainu: 3 languages (Glottolog)Bororoan: 3 languages (Glottolog)Charruan: 3 languages (Glottolog)Kalapuyan: 3 languages (Glottolog)Kawesqar: 3 languages (Glottolog)Peba-Yagua: 3 languages (Glottolog)Saliban: 3 languages (Glottolog)Tequistlatecan: 3 languages (Glottolog)Tsimshian: 3 languages (Glottolog)Zamucoan: 3 languages (Glottolog)Araucanian: 2 languages (Glottolog)Boran: 2 languages (Glottolog)Cahuapanan: 2 languages (Glottolog)Chimakuan: 2 languages (Glottolog)Chiquitano: 2 languages (Glottolog)Coosan: 2 languages (Glottolog)Haida: 2 languages (Glottolog)Harakmbut: 2 languages (Glottolog)Hibito-Cholon: 2 languages (Glottolog)Huarpean: 2 languages (Glottolog)Jicaquean: 2 languages (Glottolog)Kakua-Nukak: 2 languages (Glottolog)Katukinan: 2 languages (Glottolog)Keresan: 2 languages (Glottolog)Koreanic: 2 languages (Glottolog)Lencan: 2 languages (Glottolog)Nivkh: 2 languages (Glottolog)Otomaco-Taparita: 2 languages (Glottolog)Palaihnihan: 2 languages (Glottolog)Tarascan: 2 languages (Glottolog)Ticuna-Yuri: 2 languages (Glottolog)Uru-Chipaya: 2 languages (Glottolog)Wintuan: 2 languages (Glottolog)Yuki-Wappo: 2 languages (Glottolog)Aewa: 1 language (Glottolog)Adai: 1 language (Glottolog)Aikanã: 1 language (Glottolog)Alsea-Yaquina: 1 language (Glottolog)Andaqui: 1 language (Glottolog)Andoque: 1 language (Glottolog)Arutani: 1 language (Glottolog)Atacame: 1 language (Glottolog)Atakapa: 1 language (Glottolog)Basque: 1 language (Glottolog)Beothuk: 1 language (Glottolog)Betoi-Jirara: 1 language (Glottolog)Burushaski: 1 language (Glottolog)Camsá: 1 language (Glottolog)Candoshi-Shapra: 1 language (Glottolog)Canichana: 1 language (Glottolog)Cayuse: 1 language (Glottolog)Cayubaba: 1 language (Glottolog)Chimariko: 1 language (Glottolog)Chitimacha: 1 language (Glottolog)Chono: 1 language (Glottolog)Coahuilteco: 1 language (Glottolog)Cofán: 1 language (Glottolog)Comecrudan: 1 language (Glottolog)Cotoname: 1 language (Glottolog)Cuitlatec: 1 language (Glottolog)Culli: 1 language (Glottolog)Elamite: 1 language (Glottolog)Esselen: 1 language (Glottolog)Fulniô: 1 language (Glottolog)Guachi: 1 language (Glottolog)Guaicurian: 1 language (Glottolog)Guamo: 1 language (Glottolog)Guató: 1 language (Glottolog)Hadza: 1 language (Glottolog)Irántxe-Münkü: 1 language (Glottolog)Itonama: 1 language (Glottolog)Jirajaran: 1 language (Glottolog)Kanoé: 1 language (Glottolog)Karankawa: 1 language (Glottolog)Kariri: 1 language (Glottolog)Karuk: 1 language (Glottolog)Klamath-Modoc: 1 language (Glottolog)Kunza: 1 language (Glottolog)Kutenai: 1 language (Glottolog)Kwaza: 1 language (Glottolog)Leco: 1 language (Glottolog)Lule: 1 language (Glottolog)Máku: 1 language (Glottolog)Maratino: 1 language (Glottolog)Matanawí: 1 language (Glottolog)Mato Grosso Arára: 1 language (Glottolog)Mochica: 1 language (Glottolog)Molale: 1 language (Glottolog)Mosetén-Chimané: 1 language (Glottolog)Movima: 1 language (Glottolog)Muniche: 1 language (Glottolog)Mure: 1 language (Glottolog)Natchez: 1 language (Glottolog)Omurano: 1 language (Glottolog)Oti: 1 language (Glottolog)Páez: 1 language (Glottolog)Payagua: 1 language (Glottolog)Pirahã: 1 language (Glottolog)Puelche: 1 language (Glottolog)Puinave: 1 language (Glottolog)Pumé: 1 language (Glottolog)Puquina: 1 language (Glottolog)Puri-Coroado: 1 language (Glottolog)Ramanos: 1 language (Glottolog)Salinan: 1 language (Glottolog)Sandawe: 1 language (Glottolog)Sapé: 1 language (Glottolog)Sechuran: 1 language (Glottolog)Seri: 1 language (Glottolog)Siuslaw: 1 language (Glottolog)Takelma: 1 language (Glottolog)Tallán: 1 language (Glottolog)Taruma: 1 language (Glottolog)Taushiro: 1 language (Glottolog)Timote-Cuica: 1 language (Glottolog)Timucua: 1 language (Glottolog)Tinigua: 1 language (Glottolog)Tonkawa: 1 language (Glottolog)Trumai: 1 language (Glottolog)Tunica: 1 language (Glottolog)Urarina: 1 language (Glottolog)Vilela: 1 language (Glottolog)Waorani: 1 language (Glottolog)Warao: 1 language (Glottolog)Washo: 1 language (Glottolog)Xukurú: 1 language (Glottolog)Yámana: 1 language (Glottolog)Yana: 1 language (Glottolog)Yuchi: 1 language (Glottolog)Yuracaré: 1 language (Glottolog)Yurumanguí: 1 language (Glottolog)Hoti: 1 language (Glottolog)Zuni: 1 language (Glottolog)Atlantic-CongoAustronesianIndo-EuropeanSino-TibetanNuclear Trans New GuineaPama-NyunganOtomangueanAustroasiaticTai-KadaiDravidianArawakanTupianUto-AztecanCentral Sudanic
Families placed by the median position of their languages; circle area grows with the number of languages. Point at a dashed link to see the proposal.

Contested proposals

Live proposals defended in peer-reviewed work but not accepted as families.

Once a standard grouping

Turkic, Mongolic and Tungusic, and in the larger version Koreanic and Japonic, descend from one ancestor.

Members
Turkic, Mongolic-Khitan, Tungusic, Koreanic, Japonic“Micro-Altaic” is Turkic, Mongolic and Tungusic; “Macro-Altaic” or Transeurasian adds Koreanic and Japonic.
Proposed by
Ramstedt; Poppe; Starostin; Robbeets
Evidence offered
A 2021 study combines cognate sets from 98 languages, archaeology and ancient DNA, and links the spread to millet farmers of the West Liao River in north-east China.3
Main critiques
Most comparativists since the 1950s treat the similarities as areal, the result of long contact; Macro-Altaic is “widely rejected, even by many Altaicists”.5
A 2022 reanalysis finds that only a small share of the 2021 cognate sets appear in more than one family, and that the archaeology and genetics do not support the farming narrative.4

Debate

Did the Transeurasian languages spread with early millet farmers?

A 2021 study argues that Turkic, Mongolic, Tungusic, Koreanic and Japonic descend from one language spread by millet farmers from north-east China. A 2022 reanalysis argues that none of the three lines of evidence supports that account, and the original authors replied that combining them reduces the error. Most comparativists treat Altaic resemblances as the result of contact.

What would settle it

  • Regular sound correspondences across the five families in basic vocabulary, accepted by specialists in each.

Na-Dene of North America and Yeniseian of central Siberia (Ket) are related.

Proposed by
Vajda 2008; Kari & Potter (eds.) 2010
Evidence offered
Proposed sound correspondences and verb morphology; some Na-Dene specialists reacted favourably.8
A phylogenetic study supports a back-migration from Beringia into Asia.7
Main critiques
Campbell and others find the sound correspondences insufficient.8

Once a standard grouping

Atlantic-Congo, Mande, Dogon, Ijoid and other families of sub-Saharan Africa form one family.

Members
Atlantic-Congo, Mande, Dogon, Ijoid, KruAtlantic-Congo with Mande, Dogon, Ijoid, Kru and others. Glottolog keeps these as separate families.
Proposed by
Greenberg 1963
Evidence offered
Shared noun-class systems and lexical resemblances across much of the proposed family.10
Main critiques
Glottolog 5.4 has no Niger-Congo node and lists Atlantic-Congo, Mande, Dogon, Ijoid and Kru as separate families.11

Groupings rejected as genetic units

Once a standard grouping

The click languages of southern and eastern Africa form one family.

Members
Khoe-Kwadi, Kxa, Tuu, Hadza, SandaweKhoe-Kwadi, Kx'a, Tuu, Hadza and Sandawe. “Khoisan” stays in use as an areal and typological term (click languages of southern and eastern Africa).
Proposed by
Greenberg
Evidence offered
Click consonants and other shared typological features.10
Main critiques
Glottolog 5.4 does not group them: it has no Khoisan node and lists five separate units.11
Why it is rejected
Glottolog 5.4 has no Khoisan node: Khoe-Kwadi, Kx'a and Tuu are separate families and Hadza and Sandawe are isolates.11
Fringe proposals (8): rejected by most specialists

Most of the language families of western Eurasia and North Africa descend from one ancestor.

Members: Indo-European, Uralic, Turkic, Mongolic-Khitan, Tungusic, Kartvelian, Dravidian, Afro-Asiatic. Proposed by Pedersen 1903; Illich-Svitych and Dolgopolsky (1960s); Bomhard.

Evidence offered: Reconstructed Nostratic roots and sound correspondences between proto-languages.12

Critiques: Campbell & Poser call the reconstruction “typologically flawed”.2

Why it is rejected: Now generally considered a fringe theory with very low support among specialists.122

Wikipedia only so far: the handbook sources are still to be cited directly.

The families of northern Eurasia, from Indo-European to Eskimo-Aleut, form one family.

Members: Indo-European, Uralic, Turkic, Mongolic-Khitan, Tungusic, Chukotko-Kamchatkan, Eskimo-Aleut, Koreanic, Japonic, Ainu, Nivkh. Proposed by Greenberg 1987, 2000; Ruhlen.

Evidence offered: A statistical study of “ultraconserved words” proposes a Eurasiatic tree about 15,000 years deep.13

Critiques: Heggarty argues that the ultraconserved-words result reflects method, not deep ancestry: “faces in the fire”.14

Why it is rejected: Not accepted by most historical linguists; the comparative method has not shown regular correspondences at this depth.1214

Families and isolates from the Basque Country to North America descend from one ancestor.

Members: Athabaskan-Eyak-Tlingit, Yeniseian, Sino-Tibetan, Nakh-Daghestanian, Abkhaz-Adyge, Burushaski, Basque. Proposed by Starostin; Nikolaev; Bengtson.

Evidence offered: Lexical comparisons and reconstructed roots across the proposed members.8

Critiques: Vajda, who proposed Dené–Yeniseian, rejects the larger grouping.8

Why it is rejected: Specialists, including the main proponent of Dené–Yeniseian, do not accept it.8

Wikipedia only so far: the handbook sources are still to be cited directly.

Austroasiatic and Austronesian are related.

Members: Austroasiatic, Austronesian. Proposed by Schmidt 1906; Reid 2005.

Evidence offered: Morphological parallels between the two families.15

Critiques: The parallels have not been shown to come from a common ancestor rather than contact or chance.15

Why it is rejected: Unproven: not accepted as a demonstrated family.15

Wikipedia only so far: the handbook sources are still to be cited directly.

Sino-Tibetan and Austronesian are related.

Members: Sino-Tibetan, Austronesian. Proposed by Sagart 1990, 2005.

Evidence offered: Proposed lexical correspondences between Old Chinese and Proto-Austronesian.16

Critiques: Few specialists accept the correspondences as inherited.16

Why it is rejected: A minority proposal without wide support.16

Wikipedia only so far: the handbook sources are still to be cited directly.

Elamite of ancient Iran and the Dravidian languages are related, with Brahui closest to Elamite.

Members: Elamite, Dravidian. Proposed by McAlpin 1974–2015; Southworth.

Evidence offered: Proposed correspondences between Elamite and Dravidian words and endings.17

Critiques: Krishnamurti judged the correspondences ad hoc; a 2023 review found McAlpin's later evidence insufficient.17

Why it is rejected: Unproven: the correspondences have not convinced specialists.17

Wikipedia only so far: the handbook sources are still to be cited directly.

Almost all the languages of the Americas form a single family.

Members: Every language family of the Americas except Na-Dene and Eskimo-Aleut (drawn here as every Glottolog family of the North and South America macro-areas except those two).. Proposed by Greenberg 1960, elaborated 1987; Ruhlen.

Evidence offered: Mass comparison of word lists across many families at once.18

Critiques: Mass comparison does not separate inheritance from chance and borrowing.182

Why it is rejected: Rejected by specialists in the languages of the Americas.18

Wikipedia only so far: the handbook sources are still to be cited directly.

All living languages descend from one reconstructable ancestor.

Members: All languages.. Proposed by Trombetti; Swadesh; Ruhlen; Bengtson.

Evidence offered: Proposed global etymologies (look-alike roots across many families).1

Critiques: Called “speculative and not amenable to analysis in historical linguistics”.1

Why it is rejected: Beyond the reach of the comparative method; specialists do not accept the proposed etymologies.1

Wikipedia only so far: the handbook sources are still to be cited directly.

Sources

  1. 1.Wikipedia contributors. “Proto-Human language”. Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia. Accessed 2026-11-14. Orientation source only.
  2. 2.Campbell, Lyle, Poser, William J. (2008). Language Classification: History and Method. Cambridge University Press. Cited via Wikipedia: Nostratic languages.
  3. 3.Robbeets, Martine, Bouckaert, Remco, Conte, Matthew, et al. (2021). Triangulation supports agricultural spread of the Transeurasian languages. Nature 599: 616–621. doi:10.1038/s41586-021-04108-8
  4. 4.Tian, Zheng, Tao, Yuxin, Zhu, Kongyang, et al. (2022). Triangulation fails when neither linguistic, genetic, nor archaeological data support the Transeurasian narrative. bioRxiv. doi:10.1101/2022.06.09.495471
  5. 5.Wikipedia contributors. “Altaic languages”. Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia. Accessed 2026-11-14. Orientation source only.
  6. 6.Robbeets, Martine, Hudson, Mark, Ning, Chao, et al. (2022). Triangulation reduces the polygon of error for the history of Transeurasian. bioRxiv. doi:10.1101/2022.10.05.510045
  7. 7.Sicoli, Mark A., Holton, Gary (2014). Linguistic Phylogenies Support Back-Migration from Beringia to Asia. PLoS ONE 9(3): e91722. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0091722
  8. 8.Wikipedia contributors. “Dené–Caucasian languages”. Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia. Accessed 2026-11-14. Orientation source only.
  9. 9.Wikipedia contributors. “Austro-Tai languages”. Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia. Accessed 2026-11-14. Orientation source only.
  10. 10.Wikipedia contributors. “List of language families”. Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia. Accessed 2026-11-14. Orientation source only.
  11. 11.Hammarström, Harald, Forkel, Robert, Haspelmath, Martin, Bank, Sebastian (2026). Glottolog 5.4. Max Planck Institute for Evolutionary Anthropology. Accessed 2026-11-15.
  12. 12.Wikipedia contributors. “Nostratic languages”. Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia. Accessed 2026-11-14. Orientation source only.
  13. 13.Pagel, Mark, Atkinson, Quentin D., Calude, Andreea S., Meade, Andrew (2013). Ultraconserved words point to deep language ancestry across Eurasia. PNAS 110(21): 8471–8476. doi:10.1073/pnas.1218726110
  14. 14.Heggarty, Paul (2013). Ultraconserved words and Eurasiatic? The “faces in the fire” of language prehistory. PNAS 110(35): E3254. doi:10.1073/pnas.1309114110
  15. 15.Wikipedia contributors. “Austric languages”. Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia. Accessed 2026-11-14. Orientation source only.
  16. 16.Wikipedia contributors. “Sino-Austronesian languages”. Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia. Accessed 2026-11-14. Orientation source only.
  17. 17.Wikipedia contributors. “Elamo-Dravidian languages”. Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia. Accessed 2026-11-14. Orientation source only.
  18. 18.Wikipedia contributors. “Amerind languages”. Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia. Accessed 2026-11-14. Orientation source only.

Written for Inkglot from the sources above, with no generated text. Last reviewed 2026-11-15. Owner sign-off pending: labels follow the cited sources and await a final check against each source's own words. How we label knowledge